I am Notable and Superlative
And this does nothing for my self-esteem. (Thoughts on Chat GPT's hyper-positivity and a big announcement.)
AI is such a big deal now that I thought I’d get some help from Chat GPT punching up my bio, since I’m sending so many query letters to agents about Ten Days, Ten Pounds. Check out the first pass:
“Kristen (Baumgardner) Caven: A Trailblazing Wordsmith”
What a great epithet! And so accurate! I do blaze trails! I do smith words!
“In the vibrant tapestry of modern literature,” the bio begins, “Kristen (Baumgardner) Caven stands as a luminary, weaving tales that ignite imagination and provoke introspection.” Wow, I wasn’t expecting such poetic flattery! It’s almost as if this being has read all of my books! “With a career marked by creativity, compassion, and a relentless pursuit of artistic excellence, Caven has earned her place among the literary elite.” The first clause is true, but, um….which literary elite, exactly?
“Born with a pen in her hand and a kaleidoscope of ideas in her mind, Caven embarked on her journey as a wordsmith at a tender age. Fueled by an insatiable curiosity and an unwavering passion for storytelling, she honed her craft with determination and resilience.”
Okay, how does it know that about me? Or does it just know this is how all writers get the job done? Flattery will get you everywhere, Chat GPT! Or may I call you “Chatty G’Peety?”
“Caven's literary odyssey is adorned with accolades and accomplishments that testify to her mastery of the written word. Her debut novel, Perfectly Revolting: My Glamorous Cartooning Career,’ garnered widespread acclaim, earning her the prestigious IPPY Award for Best First Book. With prose that dances off the page and characters that linger in the reader's psyche, Caven established herself as a formidable force in the literary realm.”
Literary odyssey! Adorned with accolades! Would that word choice and alliteration impress an agent or make them want to throw up? Widespread acclaim? I’ve had a little but I’m hardly a household name…And wait a minute, did I miss something about the IPPY? Did I even submit the book for entry? Am I really that formidable? Why don’t I feel like it? Also, wasn’t it a memoir? Weren’t all those lingering characters just me?
Chat GPT goes on to say my children’s book (though it’s not a children’s book) The Souls of Her Feet, my “modern retelling of the classic fairy tale that subverts stereotypes and champions self-empowerment,” was not only “praised for its feminist undertones and lyrical prose,” but earned me “the coveted Mom's Choice Award and a permanent place in the literary canon.” Oh would that were true, but it’s so very not! TSOHF does have eleven Amazon reviews and a song from the erstwhile musical was just performed in New York and I do see it on my friends’ bookshelves…but really? Oh, Chatty Jeep, one fake award does not canon entry make!
“Undeterred by the constraints of conventional genres, Caven's literary repertoire spans across diverse forms and mediums. From whimsical children's books that spark joy and wonder in young hearts to poignant memoirs that resonate with universal truths, she fearlessly explores the vast expanse of human experience.”
Okay, well that part is 100% true.
But the point of this essay is, beware the hyperbole and excessively complimentary language. Chatty Jeep and its friends have been estimated to have helped write at least 60,000 scientific studies, which was discovered by whopping increases in rich but unsubstantiated descriptors like “intricate” and “meticulous.”
Chappy doesn’t scour the web for actual sentences or facts, and it apologizes for that constantly. Making up facts doesn’t really help anything. Making up excitement and sentiment feels pretty wonderful but creates an icky emotional uncanny valley. Even if praise is warranted, it feels empty when it doesn’t come from a person. Even if it’s true, or earned, or even accurate, because some of it is, it’s not real. It doesn’t feel trustworthy. You can’t have trust without truth.
This brings me to a big announcement.
Self-esteem, trust, and truth are deeply intertwined, and this is a good segue into my next big project. Between fielding the necessary rejection letters, I’ve finally commenced to recording the audiobook of The Winning Family (written 100% by humans, all three times), and will be publishing a chapter a week (ish) starting next week. Most of the 34 episodes will be exclusives for the inner circle, which you can join with a few dollars or by following instructions at the bottom of my “About” page.
But everyone will be able to see me go rogue in my introductions to each chapter, in which I’ll take you behind the scenes of having a famous psychologist mom and write my own version of the story, which I’ve always wanted to call The Whining Family.
Yes, long before life brought me the opportunity to actually co-author a new edition of The Winning Family or re-boot the gorgeous children’s classic Liking Myself, this was a funny bit from the back pages of Perfectly Revolting:
Who says dreams can’t come true? With a little imagination and AI (perish the thought) doing the heavy creative lifting?
Actually, I would prefer Licking Myself to be written by my sweet rescue cat, Fluffy, who had his birthday this week and is definitely the expert in this matter.
… But call it,“ licking myself”…
You’re still cool Kristen, no matter what chatty says (or oversays).. Your post contains good examples of the danger of relying on or even using ChatGPT.
If you submit “liking myself” to ChatGPT but Licking myself, I’d be tickled to read it.
Looking forward, Paul